Certainly I never read essays from thes person, but there are too many essays floating around and yours certainly was the best I ever read, and you know I am trully about that ;).
I understand your point of view about Snape, and I do agree with you about almost everything you said, but, for me SNAPE IS BAD. He have a very hugh sense of justice, but prefer to be unfair with Harry , Remus, Sirius. He has a cauldron of bad feelings boiling inside, and, despite he killed Dumbledore probably in his command, I don't think he had any remorse about Harry's parents death.
His motion is obscure for me, but I don't think it's impossible he was in love for Lilly, actually, but probably he was never not nearly loved for her, even JK said that he was loved at once in his life (probably by his mother).
And I think it's nice to reply in english in your LJ because it's a discussion that others thath don't read in portuguese can see my point of view, even my english is not too god as yours, of course :).
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
no subject
Date: 2006-11-10 08:15 pm (UTC)I understand your point of view about Snape, and I do agree with you about almost everything you said, but, for me SNAPE IS BAD. He have a very hugh sense of justice, but prefer to be unfair with Harry , Remus, Sirius. He has a cauldron of bad feelings boiling inside, and, despite he killed Dumbledore probably in his command, I don't think he had any remorse about Harry's parents death.
His motion is obscure for me, but I don't think it's impossible he was in love for Lilly, actually, but probably he was never not nearly loved for her, even JK said that he was loved at once in his life (probably by his mother).
And I think it's nice to reply in english in your LJ because it's a discussion that others thath don't read in portuguese can see my point of view, even my english is not too god as yours, of course :).